HOAleader.com - Tip of the Week - March 21, 2025
Published: Fri, 03/21/25
Updated: Thu, 03/27/25
=================================================================
HOAleader.com - Tip of the Week - March 21, 2025
=================================================================
In this week's tip, we report on a December California appellate court case that brought good news to condos and HOAs—and add a warning.
The court upheld a trial court's decision in backing an HOA after owners got into a physical brawl that caused injuries, and the injured party sued the HOA and its management company for not preventing it.
While many of our experts like that the court took the HOA's side in this dispute, one of our California experts says the case is probably not as good for condos and HOAs as it looks at first glance.
The case, Woolard v. Regent Real Estate Services, was filed by an HOA owner against the Greenhouse Community Association and its management company, Regent Real Estate Services. The parties were two couples, each tenants in the condo association, who lived next door to each other.
In December 2019, the couples began arguing, and it escalated into a physical altercation. According to the court, the brawl went from punching and kicking to assault with a flashlight and then a stabbing.
One of the couples, Eric Smith and Stacy Thorne, sued the other couple, Eric Woolard and Breonna Hall. Woolard and Hall cross-complained against the condo association and its management company, claiming the physical altercation was the result of long-standing harassment by multiple neighbors, including the next-door neighbors Smith and Thorne, and the condo president. They sought indemnification, apportionment of fault, negligence, and interference with economic relations.
The condo association sought summary judgment—meaning a decision by the judge to end the case based on the written briefs before trial. It claimed it acted reasonably and that it didn't owe a duty of care to contact police or intervene in the dispute between the neighbors.
The court held that the condo association didn't breach any duty to the residents. “But what duty did they have other than calling the police, if there was potential or ongoing criminal activity? They do not tell us,” the court stated.
The court also held that the condo association had a lower duty of care to the plaintiffs because they were tenants, not owners: “Further, there is the issue that Woolard and Hall were tenants, but not owners and members of the association. They are, accordingly, in a very limited relationship with Greenhouse…. They have no legal standing to maintain a complaint that Greenhouse failed to adequately enforce its own governing documents.”
The court finally stated:
“There is simply no law to support Woolard and Hall's contentions that Regent and Greenhouse had some unspecified duty to do something to prevent what turned into an allegedly violent dispute. Imposing a duty on homeowners associations or their managing agents to intervene and attempt to resolve disputes between homeowners (or their tenants) would place an untenable burden on these entities.
Run by volunteers, they already have enough (and some would argue too much) authority and responsibility. Associations do not have police powers or subpoena power. They cannot compel owners, much less tenants of owners, to sit down and work out their differences, and they cannot adjudicate differences except in the limited context of violations of the association's governing documents.
There was evidence here…that the Association properly responded to complaints about violations of governing documents that it received. Imposing a duty under these facts would leave associations liable for the outcome of such disputes without the tools to prevent them.”
You're probably nodding your head. But this case may be flawed. Find out why in our new article: https://www.hoaleader.com/members/5065.cfm
Best regards,
Matt Humphrey
President
P.S. This text-based email format is not an error! Based on customer feedback, we are testing whether readers find this easier to read on phones, computers, and other devices. Please let us know what you think! Click here to share your thoughts: https://www.hoaleader.com/public/department6.cfm
=================================================================
Upcoming Event
Don't Get Soaked: What Your Condo/HOA Needs to Know to About Who Maintains, Repairs, and Pays to Prevent and Clean Up Water Damage
An Exclusive HOAleader.com Webinar
With Practical Tips for Condo and HOA Boards
Thursday, April 17, 2025
2:00-3:00 p.m. Eastern
Learn more or register now: https://www.hoaleader.com/products/condo-hoa-water-damage-a.cfm
Members save $30!
=================================================================
Recent articles posted at HOAleader.com:
=================================================================
Condo/HOA Leaders' Dos and Don'ts: The Roles and Duties of the HOA President, Secretary, Treasurer, and Director
Let's first say thank you for volunteering to lead your condo or HOA, whether you're president, a board member, or serving in another role. But do you know exactly what you're supposed to be doing—and not doing—in your leadership role? In just 60 minutes, you'll get job descriptions and tips for effectively carrying out your obligations as a leader in your community.
Click here to read the full article:
https://www.hoaleader.com/products/roles-and-duties-of-condo-hoa-leaders-b.cfm
=================================================================
Tempting! Just Charge Condo/HOA Owners Who Rent Higher Assessments
In this week’s tip, we answer a question from an HOAleader.com reader who wants to know whether their condo can charge investor owners a higher assessment...
Click here to read full article:
https://www.hoaleader.com/members/Tempting-Just-Charge-CondoHOA-Owners-Who-Rent-Higher-Assessments.cfm
=================================================================
Reader Asks: Can We Charge Owners Who Rent Out Their Unit a Higher Fee?
An HOAleader.com reader asks: "I live in Ohio. I’m curious if condo associations can charge a higher condo fee to investors. We’re primarily owner-occupied, but every single time we have a problem, it’s always with an investment unit. The investors who own here never attend condo meetings, and although they don’t live on the property, they claim tax credits stating they live on the property. This is somewhat of a second question. Thoughts?"
Click here to read full article:
https://www.hoaleader.com/members/Reader-Asks-Can-We-Charge-Owners-Who-Rent-Out-Their-Unit-Higher-Fee.cfm
=================================================================
Feds Halt Enforcement of the Corporate Transparency Act
Calling it "a victory for common sense," U.S. Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent today announced that the Treasury Department won’t enforce any penalties or fines associated with the beneficial ownership information reporting rule under the existing regulatory deadlines for the Corporate Transparency Act...
Click here to read full article:
https://www.hoaleader.com/members/Feds-Halt-Enforcement-Corporate-Transparency-Act.cfm
=================================================================
Taking on a Big Project? Your Condo/HOA Manager Might Be Your Best Choice to Manage It (or Not)
In this week’s tip, we begin to walk you through whether you need to hire a project manager—separate from your community association manager—for a big project...
Click here to read full article:
https://www.hoaleader.com/members/Taking-on-Big-Project-Your-Condo-HOA-Manager-Might-Be-Your-Best-Choice-Manage-It-or-Not.cfm
=================================================================
To Hire a Project Manager or Not? That Is the Question for Your Condo/HOA
Some contracts with community association managers include a provision saying they’ll charge extra to manage large projects. And those fees can add up...
Click here to read full article:
https://www.hoaleader.com/members/Hire-Project-Manager-or-Not-That-Question-for-Your-Condo-HOA.cfm
=================================================================
SPECIAL REPORT DOWNLOAD
Condo and HOA Financials: How to Report, Manage, and Protect Your Association's Money
This report will help you more effectively oversee the finances underpinning all of your operations. We've sought the advice of legal and management experts nationwide to compile this comprehensive report on the best practices for handling financial reporting and management at your association.
Members can download the report here:
https://www.hoaleader.com/public/Condo-HOA-Financials-How-Report-Manage-Protect-Your-Associations-Money.cfm
Not a member yet? Start your free trial membership and download your copy today:
http://www.hoaleader.com/details.cfm
=================================================================
Get your own copy!
Subscribe to the HOAleader.com Tip of the Week here:
https://www.hoaleader.com/public/department49.cfm
=================================================================
Please feel free to forward the *entire text* of this email to others.
Copyright 2025, Plain-English Media, LLC
(866) 641-4548
https://www.hoaleader.com
Plain-English Media, 909 Marina Village Parkway #183, Alameda, CA 94501, USA
To unsubscribe or change subscriber options, visit:
https://www.aweber.com/z/r/?ThisIsATestEmail